Outside of a dog, a book is man's best friend. Inside of a dog it's too dark to read. ~Groucho Marx

Sunday, February 28, 2010

Frederick Douglass: Narrative of the Life of a Slave


Well, this is actually not a Newbery book. But I read this book recently and I enjoyed it a lot. My mom did not read this to me. People might think she read it to me. She didn't. Frederick Douglass tells this book very realistically, you can picture everything that is happening. He goes into the hardships of slavery, he gives examples. The way Frederick Douglass lived made this powerful and interesting. He lived in an uncanny place. The one downside was, he didn't tell about how he escaped. He didn't want to tell how he escaped because he didn't want the people who helped him to get in trouble, but this story would have been better if you learned about his escape. This is fair that he didn't want to endanger the people's lives, but it sucks for the reader. Now, I wouldn't mind finding out how he escaped, if he just told us, even without giving names. He could have used fake names.

It's a great story, though. He tells this story in a powerful, realistic way. Even though the book is short, he is very thorough. He never messed up in terms of losing my interest. The book feels like a novel in parts because of the way he tells it, but it isn't, which is cool. Plus, he tells a lot more than what our textbooks just do. He really magnitudes it.

Thursday, February 4, 2010

When You Reach Me Vs. Where the Mountain Meets the Moon



Where the Mountain Meets the Moon has a happy ending because the main characters both get what they need, like Minli, gets home and her town becomes beautiful. Her friend, the dragon, is reunited with the Jade Dragon, his mother. I liked the ending.

I think When the Mountain Meets the Moon is a better book than When You Reach Me. I am almost done with When You Reach Me. When You Reach Me ties in to the book A Wrinkle in Time. Both books are about a girl, who has a friend who is a boy, much like A Wrinkle in Time. Both books are involved with the supernatural. If you liked A Wrinkle in Time, you'll like this book, too, even though it has a bad cover.

When You Reach Me I'd rank about four. For Where the Mountain Meets the Moon, even though this is an honor book, not an award winner, I think I'd rank it below Young Fu. Young Fu rocked. This was still a great book, though.

Well, both When the Mountain Meets the Moon and When you Reach Me are good books. I think When the Mountain Meets the Moon has a broader audience. This is a book that anyone can enjoy. When You Reach Me is more of a mystery/sci fi story, and it it will not appeal to younger children. Like, my four year old sister and I both liked Where the Mountain Meets the Moon, and I don't think she'd like When You Reach Me. They are both great books.